What do you do when you like an item so much and it comes in multiple colors and couldn’t decide which one to buy?

I havent bought shoes in so so long because I’ve been waiting for the perfect style to come along and when it did, it also came with 3 colorways and now I can’t decide because each one is just equally pretty.

I’ve had half a mind to get two because I know it will suit a great deal of my outfits but the logical side of me tells me it might be a bit too much of an indulgence. Has anyone experienced this? Not just in shoes but in other items as well? And if so, what advice can you give me?