Struggling to move on from a textbook chapter until I have mastered its material 100%. How do you approach language learning by thrusting you'll learn some things naturally and by exposure?
Our take
In the realm of language learning, there exists a curious paradox: the more we seek to master the minutiae of a language, the more we risk losing sight of its very essence. This sentiment resonates deeply with the experiences shared by a user grappling with the intricacies of French, a journey marked by the weight of systematic learning and the pressure of perfectionism. As detailed in her post, the struggle to transition from a methodical approach, honed during high school German lessons, to a more organic style of acquiring French has left her feeling ensnared in a web of vocabulary lists and grammar rules, reminiscent of the challenges faced by many language learners today. For those who find themselves at a similar crossroads, the insights gleaned from her experience open up a dialogue about what it truly means to learn a language effectively.
The crux of her dilemma lies in the desire for absolute mastery before progressing—a noble pursuit that is often counterproductive. This internalized belief, shaped by rigorous educational practices, can stifle creativity and hinder the natural acquisition of language. As we delve into this topic, it's essential to consider alternative methodologies that embrace a more fluid approach to learning. For instance, in our previous piece on Best practices learn to to read/write for heritage speakers, we explored how immersion and exposure can facilitate language acquisition far beyond rote memorization. The user’s reliance on creating Anki decks and exhaustive vocabulary drills, while well-intentioned, risks transforming language learning into a chore rather than an exploration of a vibrant new world.
Moreover, the notion of learning by exposure—allowing oneself to absorb the language through everyday interactions, media consumption, and even mistakes—can be liberating. The user’s commitment to engaging with resources like the Coffee Break French podcast is a step in the right direction, serving as a reminder that listening and speaking are equally as vital as reading and writing. This is echoed in our exploration of strategies in the article Intensive language program -- strategies, where we highlight the importance of finding joy in the process of learning. Language is inherently social; it thrives on connection and conversation, and thus, stepping away from the confines of textbooks can often yield richer, more nuanced understanding.
Ultimately, the user’s narrative encapsulates a broader truth that resonates with anyone who has ever attempted to learn something new. The pressure to achieve perfection can overshadow the joy of discovery, leading to frustration that diminishes motivation. As she seeks advice on how to trust the process and embrace the messy, often chaotic nature of language acquisition, we are reminded that there is no one-size-fits-all methodology. The exploration of language is a personal journey, unique to each learner.
In light of this, we invite readers to reflect: what does it mean to trust the process? Is it possible to find a balance between structured study and experiential learning? As we continue to navigate the complexities of language acquisition, let us remain open to the unexpected pathways that can lead us to fluency—not through rigid adherence to rules, but through the playful, curious spirit that language learning demands. After all, isn’t there something beautifully human about stumbling through a new tongue, finding joy in our mispronunciations and misunderstandings?
Hey all,
My native language is Bulgarian and I live in an English speaking country. I have just started trying to learn French (TL) through English as that's what I'm more comfortable with. Bulgarian and some background in learning German are helping with a lot of the french grammar concepts though.
Tldr: My issue is, I am really struggling finding a good approach/routine. I struggle with spending too much time trying to learn every single detail of a chapter before moving to the next.
For some context which explains my approach to language learning:
I remember in high school we had a foundation year during which 80% of our classes were spent learning German. During the first couple of months we would learn 20+ new words a day. In order to memorise them, each of the words we had to write down 20 times and use to form a sentence with. Then we would be quizzed on them the next day and do loads of speaking/ writing/ listening/ fill in the blanks exercises in class using 3-4 different exercise books.
This made me get used to a very detailed and intense way of learning a language.
Now, with French I have the following issue.
I picked up Easy French step by Step and the McGraw-Hill Education Easy French Reader to start with. I feel like if I just read the texts and do the exercises, i will not learn anything. Instead I end up writing down each new word and all of its variations into an Anki deck with audio, I write my own sentences (by translating from English), then I practice the vocabulary of that chapter until I remember and pronounce well about 60% of it. Then I do the exercises and if I can do them without looking up too many of the words/grammar then I move onto the next chapter.
Unfortunately this means it could take me about a week to do just 1 chapter.
In terms of listening and speaking, I am currently listening to coffee break french podcast and the Paul Noble Audiobook - about 30min a day - practicing speaking with the audio.
As I'm still a complete beginner, I can't write my own texts and am struggling to say anything more than just simple phrases. This feels super frustrating and makes me focus even more on the details of each chapter I read from the above-mentioned books.
I know this is not practical, but I am struggling figuring out a better approach. Do you guys have any advice? How do you trust the process if seeing results is so slow? What worked for you? How do you deal with learning new material without spending 90% of the time drilling vocabulary?
[link] [comments]
Read on the original site
Open the publisher's page for the full experience
Related Articles
- Intensive language program -- strategiesApologies in advance for a lengthy post. I have been writing this post in my head for weeks to this community but often felt overwhelmed with all my many questions. Questions/advice wanted: How do I best amplify my learning and move toward fluency? Background: I am fluent-ish (rusty these days due) in Spanish and a native English speaker. Currently, I am in an intensive Swedish language program in Sweden that is very heavily focused on grammar and more tradition language learning. Lots of grammar workbook exercises, lots of conjugating of verbs or pluralization practice of nouns (definite, indefinite articles, etc.), and lots of othe grammar stuff. On my own, I have learned about Gabriel Wyner's Fluent Forever approach and a friend of mine recently told me about Krashen. I'm struggling because I find that their approaches sort of conflict with my program. I'm trying to figure out how to be approach my program and my learning. I get about 300-400 new phrases/words/verbs a week through my language program's Quizlet links and I find it super "meh" in terms of learning. I have tried Anki (how do people do that without a lot of tech knowledge?!) with the help of my husband, but my flashcards are still just Swedish to English with Google voices added to the Swedish. I am not really sure how to add images to complex verbs or phrases. I also am unsure how to add images to 300-400 (sometimes more!) new cards per week and actually get through those decks in addition to all of the other work I have to do in this program. There is also about 4 hours of group work a week in addition to the 7 hours of lecture, that often just feels like the blind leading the blind. We all sit around with our super low-level Swedish and our heavy accents trying to have conversations on given topics. Input issues and approaches: My husband speaks little to no Swedish. We speak English at home with our children. I try to consumer as much Swedish media as possible, but to be honest I don't have much time for that since I'm in this intense program that takes up about 50 hours a week. But I listen to a few slower Swedish podcasts, in addition to my textbook's listening exercises. I have tried to talk to my children in Swedish (they are learning through pure immersion at their elementary schools), but often they just ignore me. Haha. When we occassionally watch TV, we often do opt for Swedish. But I'm not a big TV watcher (again, don't have time!). I'm currently reading a book in my course and I think I understand about 50-60% of the words. I read it to get the gist, write down any words that either keep me from understanding a twist in the plot or words that come up frequently. Dealing with vocabulary: I have thought about copying my weekly word and phrase lists into Gemini and asking it to help me create conversations with it (AI) using that vocabulary. I thought maybe this would help me more with production. Getting practice with native speakers: I have reached out to some elderly people in my apartment building and I'm having coffee with them about once a week to practice speaking with native Swedes. I will continue doing that but damn it must be painful to speak with me. haha. I talk to nearly everyone in Swedish. Shop keepers, neighbors, bus drivers, etc. When people switch over to English, I kindly ask them for us to keep speaking in Swedish unless it is something very important (finances, legal, or pertinent health issues). What advice do you all have? I know that is a big question. How should I approach all the vocab? I keep having Spanish leave my mouth when I'm trying to speak Swedish. I assume this is normal (happening to my kids, too). How do I handle this? What are gaps in my approach? How can I hack it better? submitted by /u/KaleCookiesCraftBeer [link] [comments]
- Best practices learn to to read/write for heritage speakersTL;DR: Does anyone else here come from a language background with deep orthography, and have you successfully learned to read without formal schooling? What do you recommend doing? My native language is Hebrew. I started learning English at 5 when my parents decided to live abroad, and I went to an international school. English became dominant for me at 8 when we immigrated to the US. I don't really know how the fluency grading people often use works, but I generally feel very conversationally fluent. I can understand and communicate about all normal daily topics (e.g., we just bought our first home, and I had no issue discussing financial topics with my dad). There will maybe 1-2 words I won't know if I listen to the news or talk to someone about something very academic, but I can almost always get it by context. I probably sound a bit uneducated, but people don't usually guess I'm American when I visit until I ask for an English menu at a restaurant. I can read very slowly with mistakes, but I am decoding more than automatically/fluently reading. I have never been taught to spell and my handwriting is awful. I have been trying all kinds of things: reading a super familiar book (Harry Potter) while listening to a YouTube recording I found of someone reading it in Hebrew (not sure if this is a good approach, just started this) Duolingo (annoying as hell, not friendly to learning to read when you already know the language) trying to sit in on Hebrew language classes (pointless, I just ended up being a tutor for other students' conversation skills) trying to journal in Hebrew (painfully slow because I have to look up how to spell almost everything) iTalki (again, poor fit because my conversational skills are fine). Would love any advice from anyone else who is in this pickle. Should I be making flashcards of common words to memorize spelling? Doing more audiobook-guided reading? Forcing myself to write more, even if sloppily? I have taken a lot of language classes in my life (ASL, Dutch, Japanese, Arabic... and English I guess but I don't remember that) to varying degrees and do fine with structured programs, but I don't know how to go about it and this situation has bothered me all my life. submitted by /u/simple-solitude [link] [comments]