smart home device

iFixit's spooty teardown finds Apple's HomeView is a gluey nightmare inside

iFixit ripped a connector, snapped a speaker in two, and put more force on a logic board than anyone was comfortable with, all to get inside Apple's new HomeView.

3 min readThe Verge
iFixit's spooty teardown finds Apple's HomeView is a gluey nightmare inside
A disassembled Appe HomeView smart home hub.

iFixit walked into Apple's HomeView expecting the same quiet decency it found in recent iPads and HomePods, devices that finally let a repair technician breathe. Instead, it got glue, snapped speakers, and a logic board that took more abuse than a rental scooter. Our take: Apple just picked a fight with the people who fix your stuff, and the HomeView will lose that war for you, the owner, in about three years when the battery dies.

This matters because the HomeView is not some forgotten cable or a niche speaker. It is Apple's first real smart home hub, the centerpiece of a new collection that includes co-developed devices with LG and Schneider Electric, the same lineup we covered when Apple's first smart home collection is real and shipping in December. If the flagship is a gluey nightmare, the whole ecosystem starts to smell like planned obsolescence dressed up in a matching set. iFixit's teardown found the tablet section of the HomeView to be the real problem, and the damage report reads like a crime scene: ripped connectors, snapped speakers, force applied where no force should go. These are not the mistakes of a prototype. These are design decisions.

What stings is the context. Apple had been making real progress. The recent iPads and HomePods were genuinely easier to open, a quiet admission that repairability matters. The HomeView is a regression, and a violent one. It is the kind of product that makes you wonder whether the company's right hand knows what the left hand is doing, or whether the left hand just got tired of being nice. For the reader who buys this thing, the practical consequence is simple: when the battery swells or the screen cracks, you are not fixing it. You are replacing it. And at Apple prices, that replacement hurts.

Compare this to something like Bose finally sneezes a discount on its Sonos-killer speaker, where the conversation is about price and competition, not whether you can open the damn thing without a crowbar and a prayer. The HomeView is not competing on sound or smarts if it cannot survive a battery swap. It is competing on how fast it becomes e-waste.

Here is the specific takeaway: iFixit's report is not a warning for early adopters. It is a promise. The HomeView will be a brick before its fifth birthday, and Apple has made sure you cannot do anything about it. Watch the battery health indicator on that screen. When it drops, do not look for a repair kit. Look for a receipt.

From The Verge

After finding recent versions of Apple's iPads and HomePods much easier to disassemble for battery replacements or other repairs, iFixit assumed it would be the same story for Apple's new HomeView hub that looks like a seven-inch tablet stuck to a smart speaker. The reality was much different and by the time they got the HomeView apart iFixit's skilled techs had "ripped a connector, snapped a speaker in two, and put more force on the poor logic board than any of us were comfortable with."

Read the original at The Verge