Is the idea that “you can’t learn a language with a single app” legitimate?

Our take

Is it possible for a single app to make you fluent in a language? The prevailing notion seems to be a resolute “no,” often echoed by language enthusiasts and skeptics alike. Yet, what if we dared to entertain the idea that a comprehensive app could exist? Imagine a platform that seamlessly integrates reading, writing, speaking, and listening, offering tailored tools for each skill without the jarring transitions typical of current offerings like Duolingo. Picture a language-learning utopia where LingQ fine-tunes your reading, iTalki hones your speaking, and specialized grammar lessons guide you from A1 to C1—all while Anki solidifies your vocabulary. Such an ambitious app would require meticulous design to avoid disjointedness, but why should we dismiss the potential for a one-stop solution? Let’s explore the feasibility of this concept and challenge the status quo.

Edit: I don’t really think an app like this should exist, this is purely a discussion post on if you think it *could* exist AND actually make you fluent. Every time I see someone talking about a language learning app they invariably say “you know, an app will never make you fluent in a language” I always have this nagging voice in the back of my head saying “Never? Really? Never ever??”

I want to discuss the idea that one app could never be a one stop solution, I see that statement thrown around a lot but realistically, why not? I think one totally could, like if you had an app that gave you reading, writing, speaking, and listening in one place, you could have a one stop shop.

And not like what Duolingo does where you randomly jump from one skill to another and practice each skill for 5 seconds while they hold your hand. I mean straight up combining full fledged tools dedicated to each skill while allowing you to completely focus in on that skill without distraction.

Like maybe LingQ for reading, Pingo/italki for speaking, something like Snapalabra or some other AI tool for writing, and Spotify/youtube videos for listening. Throw Anki on top of it for vocab. And then carry the user through a lesson plan specifically for grammar A1-C1 (I’ve seen a lot of apps specifically for grammar but most of them are language specific)

It would be one hell of a massive app, and take a lot of work ontop of it to not feel wildly disjointed, but would that not suffice the requirements of being a single app to learn a language? Sure nothing fully exists like that today, but I do believe it’s totally doable.

submitted by /u/ironbattery
[link] [comments]

Tagged with

#language evolution#philosophy of language#humor in language#creative language use